Start from the posts, not the recaps
Recaps, screenshots and pinned summaries are the results a channel picked for you. The record that tells you something is every signal it posted, in the order it posted them, with the time of each post. Only that time fixes the prices a follower could have traded at. A screenshot taken later cannot show how a post looked when it appeared, and it cannot show the posts nobody took a screenshot of.
Keep each post as it was published
Channels edit an entry after the price has moved, change a stop, or delete a call that went wrong. We save every post of a tracked channel as it appears, along with its later edits and deletions, so a deleted losing call stays in the record. While a signal waits for its entry, an edit replaces the plan and the replay continues from the moment of the edit, never at a price reached before it. Once the entry has filled, the plan is frozen: editing or deleting the post changes nothing.
Write down the whole trade
A signal is a pair, a direction, an entry price or zone, take profits, a stop and leverage. Write all of it down before you look at the chart, because each part changes the result. A signal without a stop has no defined loss: with leverage, nothing in the post limits it. We replay such a signal with a stop as far from the entry as its first target, on the loss side, and close it, like any other, after a week at the price of that moment.
Replay it on candles from the moment of the post
Take the candles that opened after the post and skip the one the post fell into, so no signal gets a price from before it was published. We replay on 5-minute candles from Bybit or Binance. Inside one candle the order of prices is unknown, so take the worse case: the stop counts before a target, and a price gap through the stop exits at the candle's open.
Count every signal, including the ones that did not fill
An entry not reached within 48 hours means the trade never happened: the signal is cancelled and counts neither for nor against the channel. Every signal that filled counts, the losing ones included. When the channel closes a trade, cancels it before the entry or moves the stop in a reply, the replay follows from the first candle after that reply. A reply that only reports a result changes nothing, because that report is the claim being checked.
Judge a channel on enough signals
A few trades say little: one lucky call can put any channel on top. We rank a provider once it has 5 closed signals, and even then the numbers read best together: the verified result, the win rate, how often the first target was reached and the deepest drawdown of a deposit that followed every signal. Each provider page shows them side by side with its latest closed signals.